The success or lack thereof of an NBA franchise is often dependent on how well it does in the draft. High picks are expected to produce a lot of value, and a miss at the top of the draft can have a crippling effect on a franchise’s future. So how do we measure the value of a draft pick?
I wanted to do something relatively simple to measure a player’s approximate value in a given season, so here’s what I came up with:
Divide the player’s Player Efficiency Rating (PER) by 15, since 15 is league average.
Multiply the above by minutes played to factor in playing time.
Do the above for the regular season and postseason (if applicable) and add the two figures together.
In order to obtain a player’s career value, I used a weighting scheme similar to what Doug Drinen, creator of Pro-Football-Reference.com, uses for his Approximate Value metric (or AV, for short). Here’s Drinen’s description of the method:
My opinion is that most people mentally rank players by counting all the player’s seasons, but weighting their best seasons more. In order to mimic that, I’ve defined each player’s career “value” to be:
100% of his best season, plus 95% of his 2nd-best season, plus 90% of his 3rd-best season, …
So, for two players with the same career AV, the one with the higher peak will be rated a little higher. And junk seasons at the end of a player’s career count for almost nothing.
I used this process to compute the career value for every player drafted from 1985 — the first year of the NBA Draft Lottery — through 2009. Below is a summary of the career value produced by the players selected in each of the top-14 slots over that time period (i.e., choices that would be considered lottery picks in today’s NBA).
1st Overall Pick
Top 3: LeBron James (71,563); Shaquille O’Neal (58,525); Tim Duncan (56,842)
Median: Glenn Robinson (24,868)
Bottom 3: Greg Oden (2,549); Michael Olowokandi (8,173); Kwame Brown (9,722)
James laps the field when it comes to this measure, with a career value more than 10,000 ahead of the next-closest player drafted in this span:
71,563 — LeBron James
60,873 — Karl Malone
58,525 — Shaquille O’Neal
56,842 — Tim Duncan
56,680 — Kobe Bryant
54,512 — Dirk Nowiztki
53,084 — Kevin Garnett
51,631 — Kevin Durant
49,537 — David Robinson
48,780 — Chris Paul
I have a soft spot for Oden, a fellow Ohio State alumnus. Due to numerous knee surgeries, he appeared in just 105 games, the fewest for a first overall pick in the modern draft era (i.e., since 1966; excludes active players). Oden was actually quite effective when he played, averaging 14.9 points, 11.6 rebounds, and 2.3 blocks per 36 minutes while shooting 57.4% from the field.
2nd Overall Pick
Top 3: Kevin Durant (51,631); Gary Payton (44,718); Jason Kidd (41,447)
Median: Armen Gilliam (22,638)
Bottom 3: Len Bias (DNP); Hasheem Thabeet (1,550); Jay Williams (1,594)
Eighteen of the 25 first overall picks in this span earned at least one All-Star selection during their careers, with 16 of them earning multiple nods. In contrast, just 10 of the 25 second overall picks in this period were named an All-Star at least once, with four of them receiving the honor just a single time.
The careers of Bias and Williams ended on tragic notes. Bias, an All-America forward from Maryland, died from cocaine-induced cardiac arrhythmia on June 19, 1986, just two days after being selected by the Boston Celtics in the 1986 NBA Draft. The shocking death had a profound effect on the sports world: over 11,000 people attended a memorial service held for him at the University of Maryland.
Williams had an up-and-down rookie season with the Chicago Bulls, but his shooting efficiency greatly improved after the All-Star break, and he looked to be on the upswing heading into his sophomore campaign. But on June 19, 2003 — exactly seventeen years after Bias’ death — Williams was involved in a horrific motorcycle accident that nearly took his life. Although he would eventually recover and attempt a comeback with the New Jersey Nets, Williams never again played in the NBA.
3rd Overall Pick
Top 3: James Harden (47,715); Paul Gasol (43,208); Carmelo Anthony (39,353)
Median: Sean Elliott (20,467)
Bottom 3: Chris Washburn (329); Adam Morrison (1,602); Dennis Hopson (6,211)
Although not listed above, Chauncey Billups ranks fourth in career value at this slot, and remains a cautionary tale for not giving up on a player too soon. Billups played for three different franchises in his first three seasons, and it looked like he would go down as one of the bigger busts in NBA Draft history. But in his fourth season he showed significant improvement, and by his sixth season — now playing for his fifth different franchise, the Detroit Pistons — Billups had become one of the best point guards in the league.
Despite numerous red flags — poor grades, questionable work ethic, a run-in with the law — the Golden State Warriors took a gamble on Washburn in the 1986 NBA Draft. It didn’t take long for Washburn to run into trouble, and by January of his rookie season he was being treated for an addiction to cocaine. Washburn was never able to get his drug habit under control, and in June 1989 he received a lifetime ban from the NBA following his third positive drug test.
4th Overall Pick
Top 3: Chris Paul (48,780); Russell Westbrook (44,069); Chris Bosh (35,178)
Median: Chuck Person (21,621)
Bottom 3: Marcus Fizer (4,980); Tyrus Thomas (7,411); Eddy Curry (12,235)
Although he was never an All-Star selection, Person averaged between 18.4 PPG and 21.6 PPG in five of his first six seasons with the Indiana Pacers, missing just 13 games over that span. He won the Rookie of the Year Award in 1986-87.
Fizer (2000) and Curry (2001) were taken in back-to-back drafts by the Chicago Bulls, while Thomas (2006) was selected by the Portland Trail Blazers but traded to the Bulls in a draft-day deal that sent LaMarcus Aldridge to Portland. Yikes.
5th Overall Pick
Top 3: Kevin Garnett (53,084); Dwyane Wade (47,215); Scottie Pippen (42,812)
Median: Jeff Green (20,997)
Bottom 3: Nikoloz Tskitishvili (644); Jonathan Bender (2,858); Shelden Williams (4,211)
Garnett, Wade, and Pippen are probably the second-best trio at any draft spot over this time period, trailing only first overall picks James, O’Neal, and Duncan. The three players immediately following them are Ray Allen, Vince Carter, and Mitch Richmond. Allen and Richmond are Hall of Famers, while Carter will eventually be elected.
The fifth overall picks in this span have accounted for 67 All-Star selections, trailing only the combined total of the first overall picks:
126 — 1st Overall Picks
67 — 5th Overall Picks
58 — 3rd Overall Picks
54 — 4th Overall Picks
53 — 2nd Overall Picks
6th Overall Pick
Top 3: Hersey Hawkins (28,853); Antoine Walker (28,196); Tom Gugliotta (20,534)
Median: Ron Mercer (10,069)
Bottom 3: Dajuan Wagner (1,431); William Bedford (1,570); Jonny Flynn (2,749)
Hawkins was a solid player who earned one All-Star selection in his 13 NBA seasons, but it’s a bit surprising to see him at the top of this list. These players accounted for just 10 total All-Star selections, tied for the third-lowest total among the lottery spots in this span.
Brandon Roy accounted for three of those All-Star berths, and would probably rank number one at this spot in career value if not for serious knee problems that all but ended his career at the age of 26. As it is, Roy ranks ninth among sixth overall picks (14,796).
7th Overall Pick
Top 3: Stephen Curry (42,767); Chris Mullin (31,773); Kevin Johnson (31,563)
Median: Lamond Murray (14,631)
Bottom 3: Bobby Hurley (2,072); Eddie Griffin (5,983); Chris Mihm (7,069)
Curry is a lock for the Hall of Fame, Mullin is already in the Hall of Fame, and I believe Kevin Johnson should be as well. Johnson did not have the longevity of some others, but at his peak he was a devastating scorer and playmaker.
Like fellow Duke alumnus Jay Williams, Hurley was involved in a terrible accident that nearly claimed his life, cutting short his rookie season after just 19 games. Hurley returned the following season, but he never met the expectations associated with being a lottery pick.
8th Overall Pick
Top 3: Andre Miller (33,698); Detlef Schrempf (30,023); Rudy Gay (26,716)
Median: T.J. Ford (11,203)
Bottom 3: Joe Alexander (489); Rafael Araujo (664); Bo Kimble (704)
Miller ranks 12th in NBA history with 8,524 assists, the most by any player who was never selected to an All-Star Game. He also ranks fifth for most career points by a non-All-Star (16,278).
Schrempf was a three-time All-Star selection and two-time Sixth Man of the Year Award winner. He earned his first All-Star nod playing for the Indiana Pacers in 1993, becoming the first European player to achieve the honor. In my opinion, Schrempf deserves serious consideration for the Basketball Hall of Fame.
9th Overall Pick
Top 3: Dirk Nowitzki (54,512); Shawn Marion (39,369); Tracy McGrady (37,167);
Median: Stacey Augmon (16,509)
Bottom 3: Patrick O’Bryant (370); Ed O’Bannon (1,228); Rodney White (2,615)
Nowitzki spent his entire 21-season career with the Dallas Mavericks, the most in NBA history by a player with a single franchise. However, Nowitzki was actually drafted by the Milwaukee Bucks. He was sent to the Mavericks in a draft-day trade for sixth overall pick Robert “Tractor” Traylor, who averaged 4.8 PPG and 3.7 RPG in a 438-game career.
The median ninth overall pick has produced more career value than the median sixth, seventh, and eighth overall picks. In no way does that mean a team would be better off selecting ninth rather than sixth, seventh, or eighth, but it’s interesting nonetheless.
10th Overall Pick
Top 3: Paul Pierce (44,497); Joe Johnson (33,645); Jason Terry (33,454)
Median: Andrew Bynum (14,389)
Bottom 3: Mouhamed Sene (225); Luke Jackson (447); Rumeal Robinson (5,063)
Did you know Joe Johnson is one of only 16 players in NBA history to record at least 20,000 points, 5,000 rebounds, and 5,000 assists? He’s close to the cutoff in all three categories, finishing with career totals of 20,407 points, 5,059 rebounds, and 5,001 assists.
Andrew Bynum looked like he was headed for stardom after earning his first (and only) All-Star berth in 2011-12 at the age of 24, averaging 18.7 PPG (20th in the NBA) and 11.8 RPG (third) while shooting 55.8% from the field (fourth). Bynum’s NBA career, however, lasted just 26 more games due to chronic knee problems. He missed the entire 2012-13 season after being traded from the Los Angeles Lakers to the Philadelphia 76ers following his breakout campaign, then appeared in 26 games for the Cleveland Cavaliers and Indiana Pacers in 2013-14.
11th Overall Pick
Top 3: Reggie Miller (41,425); Allan Houston (24,407); Terrell Brandon (23,905)
Median: Jerryd Bayless (8,951)
Bottom 3: Fran Vazquez (DNP); Jerome Moiso (1,175); Trajan Langdon (1,379)
The gap in career value between Miller and Houston (17,108) is larger than the difference between any other top two on this list. Miller was an astonishingly reliable player, posting 16 seasons in which he played at least 2,000 minutes and recorded a PER of 15 or higher. Only two players in NBA history have produced more such seasons: Kareem Abdul-Jabbar (19) and LeBron James (17).
Vazquez and Bias (see above) are the only lottery picks over this span who did not play in the NBA. Vazquez was drafted by the Orlando Magic, but elected to spend his entire professional career in Europe.
12th Overall Pick
Top 3: Mookie Blaylock (28,721); Thaddeus Young (25,594); Muggsy Bogues (20,341)
Median: Vitaly Potapenko (7,849)
Bottom 3: Aleksandar Radojevic (–9); Yaroslav Korolev (62); Kenny Green (333)
Blaylock is the only 12th overall pick from 1985 through 2009 to earn an All-Star selection, doing so in 1993-94 when he averaged 13.8 PPG, 9.7 APG, and 2.6 APG playing for the Atlanta Hawks. He was also an All-Defensive First Team choice that season.
Despite being the shortest player to ever play in the NBA, the 5-foot-3-inch Bogues was able to carve out a solid 14-season career. He finished in the top 10 in assists six times and has the 25th-highest assist total in NBA history (6,726).
13th Overall Pick
Top 3: Karl Malone (60,873); Kobe Bryant (56,680); Richard Jefferson (27,147)
Median: Sebastian Telfair (7,344)
Bottom 3: Marcus Haislip (635); Michael Smith (1,231); Sean May (1,792)
Even though they were both selected 13th overall, the duo of Malone and Bryant has a higher combined career value than every other top two on this list with the exception of first overall picks James and O’Neal.
Telfair, a decorated point guard in high school, came into the league with quite a bit of fanfare, bypassing college to go straight to the NBA. Telfair had one major weakness: he couldn’t shoot. Telfair shot less than 40% from the field in six of his 10 seasons, finishing with a career field goal percentage of 39.0%. He wasn’t making up for that by hitting 3-pointers, either, shooting just 31.9% on 2.0 attempts per game from long range.
14th Overall Pick
Top 3: Tim Hardaway (31,408); Peja Stojakovic (26,979); Dan Majerle (24,225)
Median: Al Thornton (6,353)
Bottom 3: Scott Haskin (140); Rich King (207); Yinka Dare (406)
Hardaway (five), Stojakovic (three), and Majerle (three) account for all 11 All-Star selections by 14th overall picks over this span.
Dare recorded just four assists in 110 career games. That’s an average of one assist every 27.5 games played, by far the worst rate in NBA history among players with at least 100 games played. The closest player to Dare is Hasheem Thabeet, who averaged one assist every 8.3 games played.



