Many years ago, Bill James noted that a baseball team’s true strength could generally be measured more accurately by looking at its runs scored and runs allowed rather than its win-loss percentage. That is, he found that one could predict future win-loss percentage more accurately by using the previous season’s runs scored and runs allowed rather than the previous season’s win-loss percentage.
The same holds true in basketball: a team’s point differential is a better indicator of its true strength than its win-loss percentage. This information can be used to find teams that either greatly underachieved (i.e., had a much lower win-loss percentage than would have been expected based on their point differential) or teams that greatly overachieved (i.e., had a much higher win-loss percentage that would have been expected based on their point differential).
Last year, I outlined how to convert a team’s average point differential into an expected win total:
For example, the 2023-24 LA Clippers had an average point differential of plus-3.3 PPG in 82 games. Their expected win total is:
The Clippers actually won 51 games, so the formula was almost right on. If this process is repeated for every team in NBA history, you’ll get a root-mean-square error of 3.1 wins* (for reference, last season’s figure was 2.8 wins).
* In seasons where fewer than 82 games were played, I prorated both wins and expected wins to an 82-game schedule.
For teams that missed their expected win total by at least four wins, I made a prediction for the following season:
If the team won more games than expected, then I predicted they would win fewer games the following season (i.e., notable overachievers will fall back).
If the team won fewer games than expected, then I predicted they would win more games the following season (i.e., notable underachievers will improve).
Among the 331 teams that missed their expectation by four or more wins and played the following season:
A total of 166 went over their expected win total, with 111 of them (66.9%) winning fewer games the next season.
A total of 165 went under their expected win total, with 106 of them (64.2%) winning more games the next season.
Overall, 217 of these “extreme” teams (65.6%) matched their prediction and 114 (34.4%) did not. Considering that no other factors were taken into account — most notably roster changes — that seems like a noteworthy result.
Let’s take a look at the five teams that missed their expected win total by four or more games in 2023-24, and make some educated guesses about their prospects for the upcoming season.
Boston Celtics
Actual: 64 wins
Expected: 68.1 wins
Difference: minus-4.1 wins
Naive Prediction: more than 64 wins in 2024-25
The Celtics average point differential last season was plus-11.3 PPG, the fifth-highest such figure in NBA history. That figure was padded by 10 wins of 30 or more points, tying them with the 1971-72 Milwaukee Bucks for the most such wins in league history.
Boston will be fighting an uphill battle to reach 64 wins once again, as only two franchises in NBA history have won at least 64 games in consecutive seasons: the Chicago Bulls (1995-96 and 1996-97) and the Golden State Warriors (2014-15, 2015-16, and 2016-17).
Prediction for 2024-25: My naive rule says the Celtics should win more games this season, but that seems unlikely to happen. Kristaps Porzingis probably won’t play until December, at the earliest, and is likely to be on a minutes restriction for some time. Porzingis’ frontcourt mate, 38-year-old Al Horford, will once again play a somewhat limited role in the regular season to keep him fresh for the playoffs. I still think Boston will be the class of the Eastern Conference, but I’d peg them for 58-60 wins.
Charlotte Hornets
Actual: 21 wins
Expected: 15.8 wins
Difference: plus-5.2 wins
Naive Prediction: fewer than 21 wins in 2024-25
The Hornets were basically the mirror image of the Celtics; they lost nine games by 30 or more points, tied for the fourth-most such losses in NBA history. Those blowout losses, of course, drive down their average point differential, which drives down their expected win total.
Star guard LaMelo Ball once again struggled with injuries, missing 60 games. Although Charlotte only won seven of the 22 games in which Ball did suit up (a 26-win rate over 82 games), they were even worse without him, going 14-46 (a 19-win rate).
Prediction for 2024-25: I’m going to disagree with my naive rule once again, as I don’t believe the Hornets will win fewer games this season. Assuming better health from Ball (a risky proposition, for sure) and improvement from All-Rookie selection Brandon Miller, I think Charlotte will be good for 30-32 wins.
Los Angeles Lakers
Actual: 47 wins
Expected: 42.7 wins
Difference: plus-4.3 wins
Naive Prediction: fewer than 47 wins in 2024-25
The Lakers went 18-6 in games decided by five or fewer points last season, the best such win-loss percentage in the NBA. In fact, no other team won more than 13 such games.
Is this something the Lakers can continue to do? Well, in the three seasons prior to 2023-24 they had records of 9-9 (2020-21), 13-13 (2021-22), and 11-13 (2022-23) in close games, so it seems rather unlikely.
Los Angeles also had relatively good health last season, as Anthony Davis played a career-high 76 games, while LeBron James’ 71 appearances were his most since the 2017-18 campaign.
Prediction for 2024-25: I agree with the naive forecast. With a new head coach (JJ Redick) and two aging stars — one of whom will turn 40 years old in December — the Lakers will probably be in a fight for a Play-In Tournament spot once again. Los Angeles’ record in close games should drift back toward .500, so I’d pencil them in for 41-43 wins.
Memphis Grizzlies
Actual: 27 wins
Expected: 22.4 wins
Difference: plus-4.6 wins
Naive Prediction: fewer than 27 wins in 2024-25
So many things went wrong for the Grizzlies in 2023-24, including:
All-NBA guard Ja Morant was suspended the first 25 games of the season, returned for nine of the next 10 games, then missed the remainder of the campaign with a shoulder injury.
Desmond Bane, who averaged 21.5 PPG in 2022-23, missed almost half the season (40 games) with an ankle injury.
Marcus Smart, an offseason acquisition and former Defensive Player of the Year, missed 62 games due to injuries.
Starting center Steven Adams missed the entire season with a knee injury.
Forward Brandon Clarke, a solid bench player, missed the first 72 games due to a torn Achilles suffered the previous season.
All told, Memphis had 33 players appear in at least one game, an NBA record. They used 51 different starting lineups, the most by any team since the league began tracking starters in 1970-71. Quite honestly, it’s amazing head coach Taylor Jenkins squeezed 27 wins out of that squad.
Prediction for 2024-25: I’m going to disagree with my naive rule for the third time, as I think the Grizzlies will blow past the 27 wins they recorded last season. As you can see from the above, last season was a historical outlier in terms of misfortune. With even average luck in 2024-25, I think Memphis will win 47-49 games and be a playoff team.
New Orleans Pelicans
Actual: 49 wins
Expected: 53.3 wins
Difference: minus-4.3 wins
Naive Prediction: more than 49 wins in 2024-25
The Pelicans won 32 games by double digits last season, tying them with three other teams for the second-most such wins in the NBA. However, they tied two other teams for the league’s fourth-worst win-loss percentage in games decided by five or fewer points (6-9, .400).
New Orleans relies on two players with a spotty track record of availability. Brandon Ingram has not played in more than 64 games since his rookie campaign, missing 103 games in five seasons with the Pelicans. And although Zion Williamson appeared in a career-high 70 contests last season, he missed 194 out of a possible 308 games his first four seasons in the league.
Prediction for 2024-25: The Pelicans have only posted one 50-win season in franchise history, going 56-26 in 2007-08. My naive rule says to expect a second one this season, but for the fourth time in five cases I’m going against that guideline. New Orleans acquired guard Dejounte Murray from the Atlanta Hawks, but I suspect they’re going to miss center Jonas Valanciunas more than most people expect. I think the Pelicans will be a playoff team once again, but with a win total in the 46-48 range.



